Are ETFs as Safe as You Think?

Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) offer investors an easy and affordable way to diversify across a broad range of assets, but they are not without risks. While they may appear straightforward, understanding the potential risks is essential for ensuring long-term success. Here are some key risks to keep in mind:

‍

⚠️ Market Risk

As with any investment, ETFs are exposed to market risk. When the broader market declines, so does the value of the ETFs tracking it. Even the most diversified ETF can be hit hard by market volatility, as was evident during the 2008 financial crisis when broad-market ETFs like SPY (which tracks the S&P 500) dropped over 50%.

ETFs are only as safe as the assets they hold. If the underlying securities (stocks, bonds, commodities, etc.) are risky or volatile, the ETF will reflect those risks, especially in more volatile markets.

‍

📉 Tracking Error

ETFs are designed to replicate the performance of an underlying index. However, they can deviate slightly due to fees, trading costs, and other factors. This deviation, known as tracking error, means your ETF might not perfectly match the index returns you expect.

‍

💧 Liquidity Risk

Some ETFs, especially those focusing on niche markets, can suffer from low liquidity. This means it may be harder to buy or sell the ETF at your desired price. For example, during market panics, even relatively well-known ETFs can see their liquidity dry up, potentially leading to larger bid-ask spreads and higher costs when trading.

‍

🔎 Composition Risk

ETF investors might not always realize what they own. Some ETFs may appear diversified but are heavily weighted toward a few key stocks or sectors. For example, many "tech-focused" ETFs are dominated by a handful of companies like Apple, Microsoft, and Google. This concentration risk can make a seemingly diversified portfolio more vulnerable to sector-specific downturns.

‍

💸 Tax Risk

Equity and Bond ETFs are generally tax-efficient. Dividends are taxed as qualified dividends or ordinary income, and selling ETFs incurs capital gains taxes based on the holding period. Commodity ETFs, often structured as partnerships, requiring more complex tax forms like K-1s. The 60/40 tax rule applies, taxing 60% of gains as long-term and 40% as short-term, regardless of holding period. Precious Metals ETFs backed by physical metals are taxed as collectibles, with higher long-term capital gains rates. Currency ETFs can be taxed as either ordinary income or under the 60/40 rule, depending on structure. Understanding the tax structure of your ETFs is crucial to avoid surprises and optimize returns.It’s important to check the fund's prospectus for specific tax treatment.

‍

🤝 Counterparty Risk

ETFs that use derivatives, such as leveraged ETFs, expose investors to counterparty risk. In these cases, if the party on the other side of the derivative fails to meet its obligations, investors could suffer losses.

‍

⚠️ Delisting & Broken ETFs

ETFs can also be delisted. Niche, leveraged and inverse ETFs are prone to higher risk closure. Always a good idea to keep an eye on assets under management. Many funds close due to low assets. Another issue is the concept of a "broken ETF," where an ETF no longer tracks its index effectively. During the 2020 market crash, some bond ETFs deviated significantly from their underlying assets, causing confusion and losses for investors.

‍

🌍 Currency Risk

International ETFs are subject to currency risk, meaning fluctuations in exchange rates can impact returns. 

‍

👨‍💼 Management Risk

Even though most ETFs are passively managed, some are actively managed, which introduces risks associated with the decisions made by the fund manager, including the potential for underperformance or deviations from the stated investment strategy.

‍

✅ Takeaway

In short, while ETFs offer many benefits, they aren’t risk-free. Understanding these risks can help you make smarter, more informed investment decisions.

Happy Long-Term Investing from the Quantlake Team!