Compare ETFs With Sharpe Ratio: Simple Risk-Return Guide

At Quantlake, our mission is to make financial data simple and comprehensive for you. One tool that can help in making informed decisions is the Sharpe Ratio. Let’s break it down and see how it can be used to compare two ETFs.

‍

What is the Sharpe Ratio?

The Sharpe Ratio helps quantify an investment's risk-adjusted return. Simply put, it measures how much extra return you get (above a risk-free rate) compared to the volatility you experience. 

Here's the formula:

Sharpe Ratio = (Average Return - Risk-Free Rate) / Volatility

Average Return: The gain you make from your investment.

Risk-Free Rate: The safe harbor—usually the yield on government bonds.

Volatility: Picture a roller coaster. It measures how much an investment’s price bounces around. High volatility? Hold on tight! Low volatility? Smooth sailing. Remember, volatility isn't inherently bad; it's the price you pay for potentially higher returns. But excessive volatility can wreak havoc on your emotional well-being!

‍

Pros and Cons of the Sharpe Ratio

Pros:

1. Simplicity: Easy to calculate and understand.
2. Comparative Tool: Great for comparing different investments, portfolios, and even that rare Pokémon card collection.

Cons:

1. Sharpe Ratio: Relies on historical data, which might not predict future performance.
2. Volatility Bias: It treats upside and downside volatility equally. Life isn’t always fair.

‍

Alternatives to Consider (more exist)

1. Sortino Ratio: Similar to Sharpe, but penalizes downside volatility, potentially providing a more accurate picture for risk-averse investors (Sortino & van der Meer, 1991).
2. Maximum Drawdown: Measures the largest peak-to-trough decline during a specific period.
3. Treynor Ratio: Uses beta instead of standard deviation, focusing on systematic risk.
4. Calmar Ratio: Compares returns to the maximum drawdown, useful for long-term investments.

‍

Comparing Two ETFs: Technology vs. Utilities

Let's see how the Sharpe Ratio can help us decide between a Technology ETF and a Utilities ETF with a 2% risk-free rate.

• Technology ETF: Annual return = 8%, volatility = 10%
• Utilities ETF: Annual return = 6%, volatility = 5%

Here's the calculation:

• Technology ETF Sharpe Ratio: (8% - 2%) / 10% = 0.6
• Utilities ETF Sharpe Ratio: (6% - 2%) / 5% = 0.8

‍

What Does This Mean?

While the Technology ETF offers higher returns, the Utilities ETF provides better risk-adjusted returns, as indicated by its higher Sharpe Ratio. This means that per unit of risk, the Utilities ETF is giving you more return than the Technology ETF.

Remember: The "best" ETF depends on your individual risk tolerance and investment goals.

‍

Evidence-Based Insights

Studies, such as those by Bodie, Kane, and Marcus (2014) in their book "Investments," have consistently shown the importance of using risk-adjusted measures like the Sharpe Ratio in investment decisions. Additionally, Fama and French's (1992) research on factors like market risk, size, and value impacting returns further supports the need for tools like the Sharpe Ratio to effectively evaluate investment performance.

‍

Conclusion

By understanding and utilizing the Sharpe Ratio, you can make more informed and data-driven investment decisions. It allows you to compare the risk and return profiles of different investments, ensuring you choose the one that aligns with your investment goals.  Quantlake calculates the Sharpe ratio for all its portfolios and remember, long-term investing is a marathon, not a sprint. 

‍

Happy Long-Term Investing from the Quantlake Team!