3 Deadly Emotional Biases to Avoid in ETF Investing

Investing should be straightforward, but our emotions often get in the way of making sound decisions. At Quantlake, we've observed how even experienced investors fall prey to psychological traps that undermine their long-term success. Let's explore the three most dangerous emotional biases and how you can combat them with evidence-based strategies.

‍

1. 🔥 FOMO: The Performance Chaser's Downfall

You've likely felt the temptation to jump into a trending ETF after seeing its impressive recent performance. This "fear of missing out" leads many investors to buy high and sell low—the exact opposite of successful investing.

Research confirms how damaging this behavior can be. The landmark DALBAR Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior study consistently shows that average investors significantly underperform market benchmarks due to poor timing decisions. In their 2023 report, the average equity fund investor experienced -21.17% returns in 2022, underperforming the S&P 500 by over 3 percentage points.

How to overcome it: Implement a systematic rebalancing strategy. For instance, Vanguard research shows that annual rebalancing with a 5% threshold provides an effective balance between risk control and cost minimization. By committing to a predetermined schedule, you remove the emotional component from your decision-making. This reduces the temptation to chase performance based on recent trends, allowing you to stay focused on your long-term goals rather than momentary market swings.

‍

2. 📊 The Disposition Effect: Holding Losers, Selling Winners

When your ETF holdings decline in value, you might find yourself reluctant to sell at a loss, hoping they'll recover. Conversely, you might be quick to sell winners to lock in gains. This psychological tendency, known as the disposition effect, was documented by researchers Shefrin and Statman (1985), who found that investors have a strong preference for selling winners rather than losers.

Terrance Odean's research analyzing trading records of 10,000 accounts found that the average investor's reluctance to sell losing investments led to suboptimal returns, particularly in taxable accounts (Odean, 2002). This behavior ignores the fundamental purpose of investing—maximizing after-tax returns and maintaining a well-balanced portfolio.

How to overcome it: Focus on the future potential of your investments rather than your purchase price. Consider implementing tax-loss harvesting strategies in taxable accounts, which can both offset gains and maintain your investment strategy. Setting predefined exit rules for both gains and losses before investing takes the emotional element out of decision-making, helping you avoid holding onto losers too long or prematurely selling winners.

‍

3. ⏰ Recency Bias: Overweighting Recent Events

It's natural to give too much weight to recent market events and extrapolate them into the future. This recency bias leads investors to become overly optimistic during bull markets and excessively pessimistic during downturns.

A study by Barberis, Shleifer, and Vishny (1998) demonstrated how investors systematically overreact to consistent patterns of news. Their model showed that this cognitive error leads to predictable patterns of mispricing, with investors becoming too optimistic after a series of positive returns and too pessimistic after negative returns.

How to overcome it: Take a long-term perspective based on historical data rather than recent performance. Schwartz and Statman (2019) highlight the importance of recognizing narratives that drive market behavior while maintaining a disciplined approach to investing. By focusing on long-term trends, rather than reacting to short-term market fluctuations, you can avoid being swayed by the emotional impact of recent events. Diversifying across different asset classes can also help mitigate the impact of recency bias on your portfolio, ensuring that your investment strategy remains balanced regardless of current market sentiment.

By understanding these emotional biases and implementing disciplined, systematic approaches to ETF investing, you can significantly improve your chances of investment success. At Quantlake, we believe that acknowledging our psychological vulnerabilities is the first step toward building a more rational, evidence-based investment strategy.

‍

Happy Long-Term Investing!

‍

Romain Gandon, CEO & Founder of Quantlake
🔗 LinkedIn

‍